Picture Credit score: Getty Pictures
Amazon employed at the very least two union-busting consulting companies particularly to forestall its drivers from becoming a member of the Worldwide Brotherhood of Teamsters over the course of 2022, in keeping with six stories filed to the Division of Labor and obtained by Motherboard. That is notable as a result of Amazon claims that the drivers who ship its packages aren’t its staff.
Motherboard reviewed 5 stories filed to the Division of Labor, which confirmed that Amazon spent greater than $14.2 million complete on anti-union consulting in 2022. Of that, $160,595 went to Optimum Worker Relations and Motion Assets, who, on their very own stories, particularly referred to “drivers” because the goal group of their persuasion. Amazon and the contractors it employed are required to file these stories with the federal government annually.
Amazon’s submitting references 9 contractors employed all through 2022. Each Optimum Worker Relations and Motion Assets say that one of many folks “by means of whom actions had been carried out” was Fernando Rivera, who filed a report of their very own. Rivera’s report once more identifies “drivers” because the goal group. It additionally cites “teamsters” because the union in query.
A 3rd contractor referenced in Amazon’s submitting, Authorities Assets Consultants of America, mentioned that it had been employed to steer “varied staff throughout the U.S. as could also be requested on occasion,” and didn’t specify a union. Nonetheless, the submitting refers to a different consulting group, often known as D&G Consulting, whose report filed in Might names “Amazon DSP Drivers” because the goal group, and “Teamsters” because the union.
These filings are significantly notable as a result of they present, particularly, that Amazon is making an attempt to squash unions among the many supply drivers that it repeatedly stresses are staff of third-party firms, not Amazon itself. The Teamsters have argued that Amazon is in reality a joint employer of the drivers, and is utilizing its contractor standing as a option to evade duty.
“Amazon has a stage of duty that they’re making an attempt to flee right here,” mentioned Randy Korgan, the director of the Teamsters’ Amazon Division, whose purpose is to prepare the corporate. “If the subcontractor is its personal entity, and the subcontractor employs these drivers, then what’s their curiosity in ensuring that there are anti-union consultants assembly with drivers for a corporation that they don’t have any management over?”
“It clearly identifies the quantity of management that Amazon is exerting over these subcontractors, primary,” he continued. “Quantity two, it reveals that they’ve a vested curiosity as a result of [the drivers] are staff of some kind. If you take a look at these filings, how are you going to say they’re not your drivers?”
“They simply proved they’re an employer,” mentioned Seth Goldstein, a lawyer at Julien, Mirer, Singla and Goldstein, who has represented Amazon warehouse employees unionizing with the Amazon Labor Union. “Why would they be concerned on this, in the event that they’re fearing that the [National Labor Relations] Board would rule that they’re a joint employer?”
The stories don’t reference particular Amazon areas. Nonetheless, this previous April, a bunch of drivers at an Amazon Supply Service Accomplice (DSP) in Palmdale, California turned the primary within the firm’s huge community of contractors to unionize after they joined the Teamsters, who comprise one of many largest unions within the trade. The contract ratification marked the primary time the Teamsters had efficiently organized an Amazon-related facility, and the DSP proprietor voluntarily acknowledged the union nearly instantly.
The issue was, nevertheless, that Amazon didn’t. As a result of Amazon contracts third-party firms to ship packages out of its warehouses, it mentioned that the drivers legally solely counted as staff of the DSP, referred to as Battle-Examined Methods (BTS), and had been subcontractors to Amazon. For that motive, Amazon declined to discount with the Teamsters.
Not one of the filings reviewed by Motherboard particularly point out Palmdale, Battle-Examined Methods, or the supply station, DAX8.
Amazon spokesperson Eileen Hards advised Motherboard that the filings had been “unrelated to Battle-Examined Methods in Palmdale,” and that BTS had been terminated “due to the corporate’s monitor file of failing to carry out.” She referenced six breaches of contract, 5 of which had been in January. These included grounding coverage violations—which refers to how and when a car is taken off the street on account of some security hazard—and a car security inspection violation. Motherboard has beforehand reported on Amazon’s van upkeep system.
When the unionization was first introduced on April 24, Amazon mentioned that it had terminated BTS’s contract, not as a result of the employees had been unionizing, however due to “poor efficiency.”
Hards advised Motherboard in an announcement on the time, “This group doesn’t work for Amazon. This explicit third get together firm had a monitor file of failing to carry out and had been notified of its termination for poor efficiency nicely earlier than in the present day’s announcement. This case is extra about an out of doors firm making an attempt to distract from their historical past of failing to fulfill their obligations.”
The filings particularly referencing drivers say that consulting exercise occurred between Might and September of 2022. The timeline of the Palmdale unionization course of just isn’t clear, however Heath Lopez, one of many unionized drivers, beforehand advised Motherboard that employees had began a petition in 2021 for higher working circumstances, which had served as a precursor to official organizing.
“Virtually instantly upon the employees exercising their proper to protected concerted actions, Amazon had anti-union consultants on the bottom,” Korgan mentioned. “That is Amazon’s M.O. Slightly little bit of concerted exercise goes on, Amazon sends anti-union consultants which can be making an attempt to speak to drivers and discourage employees.”
Jesse Moreno, one other unionized driver, mentioned that after the union went public, he began seeing new faces across the warehouse.
“As soon as we unionized, there was this inflow of individuals we’d by no means seen,” Moreno mentioned. “In all probability round 10 folks.”
He continued that sooner or later after the unionization was introduced, an unfamiliar man referred to as a gathering with the drivers, and mentioned that the Teamsters had been spreading a false narrative, and that Amazon’s contract with BTS had been terminated and would expire in 60 days. Throughout these 60 days, Amazon began grounding extra autos, he mentioned.
“We had been being grounded two, three-plus autos a day, which was affecting our routes,” Moreno mentioned. “If we do not have autos to drive, then we do not have autos to ship these packages, so we do not have our routes they usually’ll basically need to ship us house. So folks had been getting lower due to this.”
“The upkeep that that they had on these autos is simply horrible. Our dashboards would appear like a Christmas tree, which they did not care about earlier than,” Moreno continued. “However as soon as we unionized, if any mild was on there—they had been grounding our autos for absolutely anything. The fireplace extinguisher not being on the door, the seatbelt not retracting correctly.”
When requested whether or not Amazon can intrude with the drivers’ efforts if it says it doesn’t make use of them, Goldstein mentioned, “They’ll intrude—in the event that they’re an employer. They’re screwed. You’ll be able to’t do this. That’s hilarious.”
This isn’t the primary time Amazon has referred to as anti-union consultants to affect an organizing effort at one among its amenities. Final October, when warehouse employees on the firm’s ALB1 Albany warehouse tried to affix the Amazon Labor Union, Motherboard reported on anti-union consultants despatched in to carry captive viewers conferences and distribute fliers. When the votes had been counted, ALB1 misplaced its union election nearly by an element of 2-to-1. These consultants had been paid at the very least $3,200 per day.
